Ulster Chess Union

Ulster Chess News 2002 Number 2


UCU RAPIDPLAY QUB BELFAST 3 FEBRUARY 2002

30 players competed over 6 Rounds in 2 sections. The time limit was 25 minutes for each player.

In the Open perhaps the crucial result was Tom Clarke's victory in Round 4 over Stephen Scannell. Going into the final Round Clarke and Michael Holmes were leading on 4.5 points with Scannell their nearest challenger a point behind. In Round 6 Scannell moved up to tie with Holmes by beating him in their individual encounter, while Clarke drew a hard-fought game with Nicholas Pilkiewicz, who had also earlier held Scannell to a draw.

In the Challengers nobody escaped without tasting defeat. In Round 6 John Canning and Louis Holmes (who were leading on 4.0) were respectively paired with Chris Kelly and David Collins (who were both on 3.5) with victory going to the latter duo. Unusually the joint-winners had both lost in the first round - Kelly to Holmes and Collins to Calum Leitch.

Prizewinners: Open (1600+): 1. Tom Clarke 5.0/6; 2-3 Michael Holmes, Stephen Scannell 4.5
Challengers (Under 1600): 1-2 Christopher Kelly, David Collins 4.5/6; 3-5 John Canning, Louis Holmes, Damien Lavery 4.0

Full final standings in each section
Clarke-Moreland from Round 2 in Javascript

BUNRATTY CHESS CONGRESS 15-17 FEBRUARY 2002

A large contingent of Ulster players travelled to the biggest chess congress in Ireland at Bunratty. IM Brian Kelly, a former Ulster champion but now living in England, won the Masters with a score of 5.5 out of 6, half-a-point ahead of English GM John Nunn, with whom he drew in the final round. Of the other Ulster players, IM Mark Orr scored 3.5, while Michael Holmes, Stephen Scannell and Tom Clarke all finished on 2.5.

A report and full final standings for the Masters and the three subsidiary sections are at the official site http://members.aol.com/bunrattychess

Photographs of Ulster players at Bunratty 2002 by Damien Lavery

THE FISHERWICK TOURNAMENT 8 OCTOBER 2001 - 18 MARCH 2002

Fisherwick Chess Club ran a go-as-you-please tournament throughout the winter months. Competitors had to play at least 10 games to be eligible for a prize, with the prizes going to those with the best percentage scores. The time limit was each player having 1 hour 15 minutes for all moves. The tournament was a very closely fought affair. Gareth Annesley was leading gouing into the final night, when he was beaten by Desmond Moreland. Nicholas Pilkiewixz, last year's champion, beat Jim McLean to win the tournament. Meanwhile Robin Triggs beat Paul McLoughlin to wrest the runner-up spot from Ian Davis. The latter had to be content with a grading Prize but the luckless Annesley ended out of the prize list altogether. Also a bit unlucky was Desmond Moreland, who only played 9 games. He wanted to play 2 games in the final night to give himself a chance of a prize, but there simply wasn't enough time.

Winner           Nicholas Pilkiewicz  R.V.H. Played 16 Won 8 Lost 3 Drew 5 65.6%
Runner-up        Robin Triggs         Q.U.B. Played 10 Won 6 Lost 3 Drew 1 65.0%
Grading Prize A  Ian Davis                   Played 17 Won 8 Lost 3 Drew 6 64.7%
Grading Prize B  Damien Lavery        R.V.H. Played 12 Won 5 Lost 6 Drew 1 45.8%
Other leading scores
Gareth Annesley   R.V.H.       63.3%
Ian Woodfield     Fisherwick   62.5%
Tom Alcorn        Fisherwick   61.5%
Desmond Moreland  Randalstown  61.1%
Jim McLean        Fisherwick   59.3%

Ian Davis annotates two games from the early rounds of the Fisherwick tournament. View the two games in Javascript

Fred MacDonald (1825) - Ian Davis (1763) [C40] (Round 2) [Annotations by Davis]
Round 2 saw a very interesting encounter between Fred MacDonald and myself over a Latvian Gambit. I have added a few additional comments from the world's leading expert on the Latvian John Elburg

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 f5 3.Nxe5 Qf6 4.d4 d6 5.Nc4 fxe4 6.Nc3 Qg6 7.Qe2 Nf6 8.f3 Nc6
It is this move that questions the validity of the greedy 7.Qe2. With his next move White embarks on a rare and very sharp line, one that unfortunately his opponent is extremely well versed in. Had he wanted to play safe he could have chosen 9.Be3.
9.d5 Nd4 10.Qf2
Slightly unusual, but it normally affects a transposition. 10.Qd1 exf3 11.Qxd4 fxg2 12.Bxg2 Qxg2 13.Rg1 Qxh2 (and Black has all the play!) (Elburg)
10...exf3 11.Bd3?!
Although he didn't know it this was his first deviation from theory, not bad seeing he was clearly working it out from move 3. As said previously, 11.Qxd4 had to be played here.
11...Qxg2 12.Qe3+?! Kd8 13.Rf1 Nxc2+ 14.Bxc2 Qxc2 15.Rxf3
I relaxed here as the time my opponent had left (just under half an hour compared to my hour and ten minutes) was too small for him to offer serious resistance in the coming tactical bloodfest. Even so I took almost 25 minutes in trying to figure out the best way to press home my advantage. The main problem with this line being that Black cannot easily gain security for his King.
15...Bg4?!
Doing nothing, but more importantly missing 15...Ng4!? which may well have won on the spot.
(1) 15...Qxh2 16.Qd4 Be7 17.Be3 Bh3 18. 0-0-0 Qg2 (Elburg)
(2) 15...Nxg4 16.Qe2 Qxe2+ 17.Kxe2 Nxh2 18.Bg5+ Be7 19. Bxe7+ Kxe7 20.Rxf4 g5 (Elburg)
16.Rg3 Kd7 17.Qd4 Re8+ 18.Ne3 Qxh2 19.Rxg4 Nxg4 20.Qxg4+ Kd8 21.Ne2 Be7
21...Qh1 22.Qg1 Qxg1+ 23.Nxg1 Be7 24.Nf3 Bf6 25.Kf2 h5 (Elburg).
22.Nf5 g6
22...Qh1+ 23.Kf2 Rhf8 24.Neg3 Qh2+ 25.Ke3 h5 26.Qg6 h4 27.Ne4 Qh3+ 28.Kf4 Qf1+ 29.Kg4 Qg2 (Elburg) was much better.
23.Nfg3 Bh4
Black's play is shamefully lazy, forcing exchanges and playing to the absence of White's time on the clock.
24.Bg5+ Bxg5 25.Qxg5+ Kc8 26.0-0-0 Qf2 27.Rd3 Re5 28.Qg4+ Kb8 29.Rc3 Rhe8 30.Rf3 Qe1+ 31.Kc2 Rxe2+ 32.Nxe2 Qxe2+ 33.Kc3 Qe1+ 0-1 (time)
At last White's flag had fallen under the cynical influence of gravity.

Stephen Scannell (2181) - Ian Davis (1763) [A80] (Round 3) [Annotations by Davis]
Slaying the Steve. This was the first time I had ever played in the Fisherwick tournament, having only recently returned to the fold of Ulster chess after a 4 year absence due to University. It was the third night of the tournament and after defeating Fred MacDonald in a very theoretical Latvian Gambit I'd been unfortunate enough to be chosen by Alex Beckett to face Steve Scannell. "That'll teach you for beating me" quipped Fred as I swiftly regretted my decision not to accept Alex's invitation to play for Fisherwick that year. As it turned out though things were to end differently than expected.

1.d4 f5 2.Nc3 Nf6 3.Bg5 d5 4.Bxf6 exf6 5.e3 Bb4 6.Bd3 c6 7.Nge2 a5?!
The first (blatant) mistake in the game, played to gain space but a developing move should have been preferred.
8.a3 Bd6 9.Ng3 g6 10.Qf3 Qe7 11.Nce2 Be6 12.h4! h5 13.Nf4 Kf7 14.Nxg6!?
It would be easy to claim that Steve's major reason for playing this was that against an opponent rated 400 points below him, these kinds of complications usually favour the stronger player. However he thought for quite some time about this move, and clearly saw a strong potential in it. To be fair to him it might well have been a winning move. However it was my opinion that I was positionally inferior already, and I was thus genuinely surprised that Steve took this sharper course of action.
14...Kxg6 15.Nxh5 Rxh5 16.g4 Rh6 17.gxf5+ Kf7 18.fxe6+ Ke8 19.Rg1 Kd8 20.Rg8+ Kc7 21.Qg4 Kb6
To be honest I contemplated resigning instead of playing 21...Kb6. Both Steve and myself agreed that White looks as if he must be winning after 21.Qg4. Blacks' Knight seems to be out of the game and his other pieces cannot seem to attack anything. However I decided that White still had a bit to do to win the game, so I may as well continue for now.
22.Bf5 Ka7 23.Rc1?!
The first slip, probably 23.Kd2 (linking the Rooks) was better, as it will be ten moves yet before c4 is played. White is already coming to grips with the problem of how to convert his temporary bearhug into a win.
23...Na6 24.Rg7 Rxh4!
One thing leads to another and now Steve has allowed my only tactic to come into play.
25.Rxe7 Rxg4 26.Rd7 Rg5 27.Bd3 Bh2
Probably Steve missed this surprisingly annoying move. He also plays routinely with regard to it. It was my opinion that this Bishop needed to be pressured, not ignored.
28.Ke2 Bg1 29.Kf3?! Re8
f3 is not a secure place for white's King. In time trouble White's play deteriorated.
30.e7 Nb8 31.Rd6 Rxe7 32.Rxf6 Reg7 33.c4 Rg2 34.Ke2 Nd7 35.Rf5 Nb6 36.cxd5 Nxd5 37.Rc5 Kb6 38.Rf8 R7g3
I had to know if I was winning or not. A few moves ago Steve had turned down a draw, but now I sensed there must be something in the position for me. If I waited I felt I would only be outplayed in a technical endgame, so there was now no time for contrition.
39.Kf1?!
Now in real time trouble Steve missed the uncompromising defence of 39.Be4. Had he played this I felt he would have still had a real chance in the game.
39...Nxe3+! 40.fxe3 Bxe3 41.Rcf5 Rxb2 42.d5 Rg1# 0-1
Such was his shortage of time that Steve took 5 seconds to notice it was checkmate.

NORTHERN BANK CHILDREN'S CHESS COMPETITIONS
19 JANUARY 9 FEBRUARY 9 MARCH AND 18 MAY 2002

The Ulster Chess Union and the Ulster Schools Chess Council started a series of chess competitions for schoolchildren at both Primary and Secondary level. Originally these were intended to be for children from Primary 6 to Year 9, but such was their popularity that children in Primary 3, 4 and 5 also were allowed to compete.

More information on these events, including detailed results at Ulster Schools Chess

WATERFRONT HALL SCHOOLS TEAM CHALLENGES 12 APRIL AND 31 MAY 2002

Primary Schools Challenge 12 April 2002

This is now the fourth year running that Adrian Skelton and David Houston have organised competitions at the prestigious Waterfront Hall site. For the first of this year's two competitions there were 18 teams of 4 players. The 72 boys and girls came from 5 Primary schools - Cairnshill, Edmund Rice, Inchmarlo, St. Bernard's and St. Colums (Portstewart). In fact, more children turned up than expected, which necessitated sending out for more sets! This meant in the early rounds there were some consultation games, but the children seemed to enjoy these even more than the one-on-one combat.

Final scores (4 Rounds):
1st
Cool Cunning Kings (St. Colum's) 9.5
2nd Cairnshill Kings 9.0
3rd equal Cairnshill Pawns, Cairnshill Players 8.0
5th Cairnshill Castles 7.0
6th equal St. Bernard's Bishops, Fighting Knights (St Colum's), Noble Knights (Inchmarlo), Black or White (Edmund Rice) 6.5
10th Lord of the Kings (Edmund Rice) 6.0
11th equal Cairnshill Checkmates, Lords of the Boards (Edmund Rice), St. Colum's Castles 5.5
14th equal Ruthless Rooks (Inchmarlo), Noble Kings (St. Colum's), The Quiet but Quick Queens (Edmund Rice) 4.5
17th Portstewart Pawn Power 4.0
18th St. Bernard's Battlers 2.0

The top 4 teams qualified for the next Waterfront Hall competition where they faced teams from Secondary Schools.

Schools Chess Challenge 31 May 2002

The second of the two team events featured 16 teams - the four Primary School qualifiers from the first event plus 12 teams of pupils from Forms 1 to 3 from 6 Secondary schools (Ballyclare High, Larne Grammar, Methodist College, R.B.A.I., St. Malachy's and Sullivan Upper).

The MCB Monarchs team was in the lead from the beginning and was 2 points ahead of its nearest challengers, Sullivan Black Knights, going into the final round. The two leading teams were drawn against each other in the final round and with a 3-1 victory Sullivan drew level with their rivals. The players from both teams received winners' medals and the two schools will each hold the trophy for 6 months.

Final scores (5 Rounds):
1st equal MCB Monarchs, Sullivan Black Knights 15.0
3rd RBAI Checkmates 13.0
4th Pawn Cocktails (St. Malachy's) 12.0
5th equal St Colum's Kings, RBAI Noble Knights 10.5
7th RBAI Black Knights 10.0
8th equal Cairnshill Kings, The Rookies (Ballyclare High) 9.5
10th Ha Ha Stupid Move (Larne Grammar) 9.0
11th equal King's Pawns (St. Malachy's), Knights of the Square Table (Larne Grammar), Cairnshill Players 8.5
14th equal Pawn Crackers (St. Malachy's), Sullivan Suicidal Masterminds 7.0
16th Cairnshill Pawns 6.0

UCU BELFAST & DISTRICT LEAGUES 2001-2002 COMPLETE FINAL STANDINGS

In Division 1 this year's champions are RVH Falcons while in Division 2 Bombardier finished first. The "More Players for League Chess" competition for additional boards in Division 2 was won by Fisherwick.

Division 1

In Division 1 North Belfast withdrew after playing only 2 matches and their results have been annulled. Individual games will still count for rating purposes

Team

Played

Points

RVH Falcons

12

70.5

RVH Hawks

12

54.5

Fisherwick A

12

45.0

Bangor Carnegie

12

43.5

Civil Service

12

40.5

CIYMS

12

26.5

QUB

12

13.5

North Belfast

2

13.0

Division 2

Team

Played

Points

Bombardier

14

70.0

RVH Eagles

14

69.0

Fisherwick B

14

58.0

Groomsport

14

58.0

Randalstown

14

41.0

Hillsborough

14

38.0

Fortwilliam

14

36.5

RVH Ravens

14

21.5

[Division 1 Crosstable] [Division 2 Crosstable]
[Individual results in Division 1] [Individual results in Division 2]
[Individual Board prize winners] [Annotated games]

ULSTER TEAM CHAMPIONSHIP 14 APRIL AND 12 MAY 2002

The final of the KO Cup, as the Ulster Team Championship is generally known, was between RVH and Fisherwick. The teams were tied at 5 points apiece after their double round match, with Fisherwick winning a record-breaking 6th title on board count. The Plate competition, for first round losers, was won by Civil Service for the second time in three years.

Full report on the two Finals and an Individual Handicap rapidplay, held alongside the team finals, won by Desmond Moreland

Results from the preliminary rounds

RVH HANDICAP TOURNAMENTS 30 APRIL 2002 AND 28 MAY 2002

The RVH Chess Club held 3 handicap quick-play tournaments, open to all-comers, last summer. They proved so popular (these events are part social occasion and part serious competition) that the club is starting earlier this year, in what they hope will be a regular monthly series. The tournaments are to be held on the last Tuesday of each month from April to September. Players are handicapped on a time basis with games being of 20 minutes duration. Damien Lavery directs proceedings with calm efficiency - not easy to do when you have to fit 6 Rounds into an evening's play.

In the first of the new series top seed Michael Holmes (RVH) took first prize with a 100% score. In second place was Stephen Morgan (North Belfast), making his first competitive start in several months. Five players finished on 4.0 points. On tie-break Paul McLoughlin (RVH) won third prize, Tom Alcorn (Fisherwick) fourth and Nicholas Pilkiewicz fifth. Calum Leitch (QUB) and Chris Black (RVH) won the grading prizes.

Final Cross Table RVH Handicap 30 April 2002

No Name                Rtg  Total  1    2    3    4    5    6  

1  Michael Holmes      2117 6      8:W 12:W 18:W  2:W  5:W  3:W
2  Stephen Morgan      1986 5     14:W  4:W  3:W  1:L 10:W 11:W
3  Paul McLoughlin     1758 4      6:W 11:W  2:L  7:W  8:W  1:L
4  Tom Alcorn          1754 4     16:W  2:L  6:W 18:W  7:W  5:L
5  Nicholas Pilkiewicz 1823 4     22:W 10:L 11:W 13:W  1:L  4:W
6  Calum Leitch        1086 4      3:L 17:W  4:L 15:W 19:W 10:W
7  Danny Mallaghan     1768 4     23:W  9:W 10:W  3:L  4:L 13:W
8  Chris Black         1527 3.5    1:L 21:W 15:W 19:D  3:L 17:W
9  Paddy Scully        1000 3.5   20:W  7:L 12:L 22:W 17:D 14:W
10 Joe Clarke          1579 3     13:W  5:W  7:L 12:W  2:L  6:L
11 Damien Cunningham   1460 3     15:W  3:L  5:L 20:W 12:W  2:L
12 Des Moreland        1757 3     21:W  1:L  9:W 10:L 11:L 19:W
13 Eamonn Walls        1000 3     10:L  0:W 20:W  5:L 21:W  7:L
14 Ciaran Marron       1498 3      2:L 16:L 23:W 21:W 18:W  9:L
15 Gareth Annesley     1875 3     11:L 22:W  8:L  6:L 20:W 18:W
16 Liam McAuley        1000 3      4:L 14:W 19:L 17:L 23:W 22:W
17 Tony Parker         1774 2.5   18:L  6:L 22:W 16:W  9:D  8:L
18 Louis Holmes        1329 2     17:W 19:W  1:L  4:L 14:L 15:L
19 Steve McCann        1648 2      0:D 18:L 16:W  8:D  6:L 12:L
20 David McAlister     1685 2      9:L 23:W 13:L 11:L 15:L  0:W
21 Fred Currell        1000 2     12:L  8:L  0:W 14:L 13:L 23:W
22 Richard Proctor     1442 1      5:L 15:L 17:L  9:L  0:W 16:L
23 Geoff Hindley       1132 1      7:L 20:L 14:L  0:W 16:L 21:L

The second competition saw three players all finish on 5 points. On tie-break Tom Clarke of the host club RVH won first prize, John Bradley (Bombardier) second prize and Ciaran Marron, also RVH third prize. Of the four players who finished equal fourth on 4 points, it was Steve Scannell (North Belfast) who won fourth prize on tie-break. Grading prizes went to Damien Cunningham (RVH) and Tim Roope (unattached).

Final Cross Table RVH Handicap 28 May 2002

No Name                Rtg  Total  1    2    3    4    5    6  

1  TOM CLARKE          2134 5      6:W 18:W  5:W  2:W  9:W  3:L
2  JOHN BRADLEY        1866 5     15:W 19:W 13:W  1:L 11:W  4:W
3  CIARAN MARRON       1498 5      4:L 23:W 22:W 17:W  8:W  1:W
4  STEVE SCANNELL      2181 4      3:W 11:L  8:W 13:W 10:W  2:L
5  PAUL MCLOUGHLIN     1758 4     25:W 21:W  1:L 10:L 12:W  9:W
6  DAMIEN CUNNINGHAM   1460 4      1:L 12:L 26:W 14:W 20:W 11:W
7  DAVID MCALISTER     1685 4     14:L 25:W 12:L 24:W 21:W 13:W
8  NICHOLAS PILKIEWICZ 1823 3.5   16:W  9:D  4:L 19:W  3:L 18:W
9  RICHARD PROCTOR     1442 3.5   22:W  8:D 11:W 20:W  1:L  5:L
10 TIM ROOPE           1000 3.5   19:L 15:W 18:W  5:W  4:L 16:D
11 DES MORELAND        1757 3     23:W  4:W  9:L 12:W  2:L  6:L
12 LIAM MCAULEY        1000 3     18:L  6:W  7:W 11:L  5:L 21:W
13 MICHAEL KANE        1332 3     20:W 24:W  2:L  4:L 17:W  7:L
14 SHANE KEERS         1000 3      7:W 22:L 17:L  6:L 23:W 20:W
15 FRANK CARROTHERS    1354 3      2:L 10:L 25:W 18:L 19:W 22:W
16 ED MORGAN           1193 3      8:L 20:L 23:W 26:W 18:D 10:D
17 TONY PARKER         1774 3     21:L 26:W 14:W  3:L 13:L 24:W
18 STEVE MCCANN        1648 2.5   12:W  1:L 10:L 15:W 16:D  8:L
19 IAN WOODFIELD       1638 2.5   10:W  2:L 24:D  8:L 15:L 25:W
20 BRENDAN O'NEILL     1847 2     13:L 16:W 21:W  9:L  6:L 14:L
21 JOHN CAHOON         1187 2     17:W  5:L 20:L 22:W  7:L 12:L
22 MICHAEL HOLMES      2117 2      9:L 14:W  3:L 21:L 24:W 15:L
23 EAMONN TRAINOR      1068 2     11:L  3:L 16:L 25:W 14:L 26:W
24 DANNY MALLAGHAN     1768 1.5   26:W 13:L 19:D  7:L 22:L 17:L
25 PAUL LOGAN          1115 1      5:L  7:L 15:L 23:L 26:W 19:L
26 GEOFF HINDLEY       1132 0     24:L 17:L  6:L 16:L 25:L 23:L